Role of preoperative chlorhexidine mouth wash in the prevention of
postoperative respiratory complications
Scientific Title of Study
Role of preoperative chlorhexidine mouth wash in the prevention of
postoperative respiratory complications in patients with poor oral hygiene
undergoing elective surgery - randomized controlled trial
Trial Acronym
nil
Secondary IDs if Any
Secondary ID
Identifier
NIL
NIL
Details of Principal Investigator or overall Trial Coordinator (multi-center study)
Name
Dr Shefali Gautam
Designation
Additional Professor
Affiliation
KGMU
Address
King George medical University,Chowk, Lucknow, U.P. Department of Anesthesiology, KingGeorge’sMedicalUniversity, Chowk, Lucknow Lucknow UTTAR PRADESH 226001 India
Phone
09450610553
Fax
Email
drshefaligautam@gmail.com
Details of Contact Person Scientific Query
Name
Dr Shefali Gautam
Designation
Additional Professor
Affiliation
KGMU
Address
King George Medical University, Chowk, Lucknow, U.P. Department of Anesthesiology, King George’s Medical University, Chowk, Lucknow
UTTAR PRADESH 226001 India
Phone
09450610553
Fax
Email
drshefaligautam@gmail.com
Details of Contact Person Public Query
Name
Dr Shefali Gautam
Designation
Additional Professor
Affiliation
KGMU
Address
KingGeorgeMedicalUniversity, Chowk, Lucknow, U.P. Department of Anesthesiology, King George’s Medical University, Chowk, Lucknow
UTTAR PRADESH 226001 India
Phone
09450610553
Fax
Email
drshefaligautam@gmail.com
Source of Monetary or Material Support
Council for science and technology, U.P.
203/84, Nabiullah Road Bans Mandi, Nabiullah Rd, Bans Mandi, Qaisar Bagh, Lucknow, Uttar Pradesh 226018
Preoperatively patient will be asked to rinse his mouth with chlorhexidine mouthwash for 5 minutes
Comparator Agent
Saline mouthwash
Preoperative rinsing of mouth with saline for 5 minutes
Inclusion Criteria
Age From
18.00 Year(s)
Age To
65.00 Year(s)
Gender
Both
Details
Patients of ASA grade I/II, with poor oral hygiene (OHI more than 6), between
18-65 years of age posted for elective abdominal surgeries of less than 4 hours
duration under general anaesthesia using endotracheal tube were included in the
study.
ExclusionCriteria
Details
Patients undergoing laparoscopic surgeries, thoracic, cardiac and major
bowel surgeries and patients in which supraglottic devices were used for GA
were excluded from the study. Patients with active URTI/LRTI, COPD/asthma,
active smokers, with alcohol abuse, diabetes mellitus, morbid obesity, any
immune deficiency, heart insufficiency, those with known allergy to
chlorhexidine, those on broad spectrum antibiotics and negative consent to
participate in trial will also be excluded from the study. Patients who have not
smoked for a year or longer will be classified as not having a smoking habit.
Patients in whom prompt postoperative extubation could not be anticipated or
neurological complications appeared, or those requiring re-intubation or re-
exploration and those surgeries that extend beyond 4 hours will be dropped
from the study.
Method of Generating Random Sequence
Computer generated randomization
Method of Concealment
Sequentially numbered, sealed, opaque envelopes
Blinding/Masking
Participant and Outcome Assessor Blinded
Primary Outcome
Outcome
TimePoints
Incidence of pneumonia in postoperative period
Baseline, 3 days and 7 days
Secondary Outcome
Outcome
TimePoints
Duration of hospital stay after surgery
1 week, 2 week & 3 week
Target Sample Size
Total Sample Size="289" Sample Size from India="289" Final Enrollment numbers achieved (Total)= "Applicable only for Completed/Terminated trials" Final Enrollment numbers achieved (India)="Applicable only for Completed/Terminated trials"
Phase of Trial
Phase 2/ Phase 3
Date of First Enrollment (India)
01/08/2024
Date of Study Completion (India)
Applicable only for Completed/Terminated trials
Date of First Enrollment (Global)
Date Missing
Date of Study Completion (Global)
Applicable only for Completed/Terminated trials
Estimated Duration of Trial
Years="3" Months="0" Days="0"
Recruitment Status of Trial (Global)
Not Applicable
Recruitment Status of Trial (India)
Not Yet Recruiting
Publication Details
N/A
Individual Participant Data (IPD) Sharing Statement
Will individual participant data (IPD) be shared publicly (including data dictionaries)?
Postoperative respiratory complications account for a
substantial proportion ofmorbidityandmortalityrelatedtosurgeryandanesthesia.Severalstudiesaimed at identifying
risk factors and and predictors have been conducted acrossthe world. Various studies have shown
patients with poor oral hygiene such asactivecariesandhighplaquedepositionareathigherriskofdevelopingpostoperative pulmonary complications.
Gram negative, anaerobic, periodontalpathogensformbiofilmsondentalplaquesandmultiplywithinthemsubsequentlyresultinginperiodontaldisease,whenleftuntreated.Thisisespecially significant in the Indian
scenario where a vast majority of patientsbelongtothelowersocioeconomicstatusandlackoforalcareismoreprevalent in this strata. In addition,
studies have also focused on the preventionand
treatment of postoperative pulmonary complications and have found thatactive preoperative oral care with
chlorhexidine mouth wash plays an importantrole in preventing and reducing the development of postoperative
pulmonarycomplications by
disinfecting the oral cavity. It has also shown toreduceincidence of
surgical site infections and the length of hospital stay However,most of these studies have been limited to
patients undergoing major thoracic,cardiacandbowelrelatedsurgeriesandelderlypatientswithmultipleco-morbidities. The role of
preoperative oral hygiene in preventing or reducingpostoperative pulmonary complications in patients undergoing
other surgeries,particular short
duration surgeries, is yet to be studied. Also, the existingstudieshavefocusedonpneumoniaasthemajorcomplication.Whilepneumonia
and respiratory failure are the major contributors to morbidity andmortality,otherssuchasunexplainedfever,excessivebronchialsecretions,productive cough,
abnormal breath sounds, atelectasis or hypoxaemia are oftenoverlooked but can significantly prolong
duration of hospital stay and increasemedical
cost which can be avoided. This study thus aims to identify the role ofpreoperativeoralcareintheformofchlorhexidinemouthwashintheprevention ofpostoperative respiratory complications in patients with poor
oralhygieneundergoingelectivesurgeryundergeneralanesthesia.
3.Novelty/Innovation:
Existing studies have particularly targeted thoracic,
cardiac, bowel surgeries,neurosurgeries
and elderly patients with multiple comorbidities with focus ontheincidenceofpostoperativepneumoniainparticular.Thesesurgeriesfrequently require postoperative mechanical
ventilation with higher probabilityof
developing postoperative pneumonia, irrespective of oral hygiene status andmake up only a small fraction of the
spectrum of surgeries performed. In ourstudy,
we seek to see the role of oral hygiene independently, by removing thebiasofsurgerieswithahigherriskofpulmonarycomplications,basedonincidence of pneumonia as well as other
complications such as, unexplainedfever,excessivebronchialsecretions,productivecough,allofwhichsignificantlycontributetoperioperativemorbidity.
4.ProjectDescription:
Theproposedstudyisaprospectiverandomizeddoubleblindcontrolledtrial.Itwillbeconductedbydepartmentofanesthesiology,KingGeorge’sMedicalUniversity,Lucknowaftergettingethicalapproval,incollaborationwiththedepartment of microbiology, general
surgery and department of dental sciences,King
George’s Medical University, Lucknow. The research will be conducted overa total period of three years of which
30 months will bededicated to the
study andsixmonths eachwill bereserved fordatacollectionand biostatistics.
Samplesize:
The sample size was calculated based on a previous study that
reported that theprevalence of
dental problems was 75% in India (Varghese et al,,
2019), 95% level ofconfidence
and Error rate, usually set at 0.05 level is 4. Total 288 patients will beincludedin this study.
Varghese
CM, Jesija J S, Prasad JH, Pricilla RA. Prevalence of oral diseases and riskstooralhealthinanurbancommunityagedabove14years.IndianJDentRes2019;30:844-50
Expected outcome: Based on
the trend seen in preceding studies, we expect to find apositive co-relation between the use of preoperative
chlorhexidine mouthwash inpreventing
postoperative pulmonary complications particularly in patients undergoinggeneralanesthesia.
Feasibility:
5.StrengthofPI
Dr Shefali Gautam, presently working as
additional professor ,KGMU in department of Anaesthesiology and Critical Care. I
have total ten years experience of research activities. She has published 36
publications in various peer reviewed journals. Since the year 2015 ,she is
working as faculty at KGMU. She has supervised 6 thesis as guide ,co-supervised
14 MD/MS thesis and supervised 40 PG dissertations. In this project she will be
responsible for all experimental work and she will coordinate between the
department of general surgery and microbiology who are also part of this project.
To keep herself updated with new research findings ,she regularly attendsand conducts conferences, seminar and
workshops.
6.InstitutionalSupport:
Ourinstitutehaswelldevelopedmicrobiologydepartmentforallroutinebloodinvestigationsand cultureand preandpost op facilities.
FORMATOFRESEARCHPLAN
1.Titleoftheproposedresearchproject:
Roleofpreoperativechlorhexidinemouthwashinthepreventionofpostoperativerespiratorycomplicationsinpatientswithpoororalhygieneundergoing elective surgery under general
anaesthesia - randomized controlledtrial
2.Summary:
Background:Postoperativepulmonarycomplications (POPC)considerablycontribute to perioperative morbidity and
mortality. We have hypothesized thatpreoperativeoralcareinpatientswithpoororalhygienecanpreventthedevelopmentofpostoperativerespiratorycomplicationslikepneumonia.
Novelty: All related studies have been limited to major
surgeries thathave a higher
predisposition for postoperative pneumonia.Till
date, no otherstudy has focused on
multiple types of surgeries and postoperative respiratorycomplicationsother than pneumonia.
Objective: The primary objective is to see the incidenceof postoperativecomplications, namely sore throat, fever, pneumonia, upper
respiratory tractinfections, lower
respiratory tract infections, abnormal breath sounds in both thegroups. The secondary objectives are to
see its role on surgical site infectionsandduration of hospitalstay.
Methods: Patients
between 18-65 years of age with Oral Hygiene Index(OHI) more than 6, undergoing
elective open abdominal surgery of less than 4 hoursduration divided into 2 groups randomly.Patients with active URTI/LRTI,
COPD/asthma,activesmokers,withalcoholabuse,diabetesmellitus,morbidobesity,anyimmunedeficiency,heartinsufficiency,thosewithknownallergytochlorhexidine,
those on broad spectrum antibiotics and negative consent to participate in
trial will also be excludedfrom the
study. All the patients will be given preoperative
antibiotic prophylaxis with inj. cefuroxime 750 mg iv along with the two
postoperative doses. Group A will receive 10 ml of chlorhexidine mouthwash 0.2%
(w/v) while group B will receive 10ml of saline mouthwash for oral rinse for 10
minutes. Tracheal aspirate [broncho alveolar lavage] for culture will be
collected just prior to extubation in all patients and on post operative day 3,
and 7 if any patient develops signs of infection. CBC, Chest X Ray and CRP will
be sent on day 3 and 7 days respectively and accordingly. Core body temperature,
incidence of sore throat, excessive bronchial secretions, productive cough,
abnormal broth sounds and need for supplemental oxygen will be monitoredtill postoperative day 7.
Postoperative respiratory complications account for a
substantial proportion ofmorbidityandmortalityrelatedtosurgeryandanaesthesia.Severalstudiesaimed at identifying
risk factors and and predictors have been conducted acrossthe world. Various studies have shown
patients with poor oral hygiene such asactivecariesandhighplaquedepositionareathigherriskofdevelopingpostoperative pulmonary complications.
Gram negative, anaerobic, periodontalpathogensformbiofilmsondentalplaquesandmultiplywithinthemsubsequentlyresultinginperiodontaldisease,whenleftuntreated.Translocationof these pathogenic bacteria leads to respiratory infections.
This is especiallysignificant in the
Indian scenario where a vast majority of patients belong to thelower socioeconomic status and lack of
oral care is more prevalent in this strata.Inaddition,studieshavealsofocusedonthepreventionandtreatmentofpostoperative pulmonary
complications and have found that active preoperativeoral care with chlorhexidine mouth wash plays an important role
in preventingand reducing the
development of postoperative pulmonary complications bydisinfecting the oral cavity. It has also shown toreduce incidence of surgicalsite infections and the length of hospital
stay However, most of these studieshave
been limited to patients undergoing major thoracic, cardiac and bowelrelated surgeries and elderly patients
with multiple co-morbidities. The role ofpreoperative
oral hygiene in preventing or reducing postoperative pulmonarycomplications in patients undergoing other
surgeries, particular short durationsurgeries,is yet to be studied. Also, the existing
studies have focused onpneumoniaasthemajorcomplication.Whilepneumoniaandrespiratoryfailure
arethemajorcontributorstomorbidityandmortality,otherssuchasunexplained
fever, excessive bronchial secretions, productive cough, abnormalbreathsounds,atelectasisorhypoxaemiaareoftenoverlookedbutcansignificantly prolong duration of hospital
stay and add to the burden of medicalcostwhichcanbeavoided.Thisstudythusaimstoidentifytheroleofpreoperativeoralcareintheformofchlorhexidinemouthwashintheprevention ofpostoperative respiratory complications in patients with poor
oralhygieneundergoingelectivesurgeryundergeneralanaesthesia(GA).
6.LiteratureReview:
Ploenes T et
al(2022)[1]carried outa prospective observational study on 230adult adult patients undergoing elective thoracic surgeryto see the co-relationof oral health status onperioperative outcomes. They found that
patients withfrequentdentalvisitsandtreatedteethhadalowerriskforpostoperativecomplications compared with patients without regular visits and
patients with ahigh burden of caries
had a significantly increased risk for pneumonia. Theythusconcludedthat pathologicaloralhealthstatusisamodifiablefactorpredictingpostoperativecomplicationsand
pneumonia.
Itohara C et
al(2020)[2]conducted a retrospective observational
study on 441consecutive patients who
underwent surgery for lung cancer to evaluate thetrendsinthenumberoforalbacteriaintheperioperativeperiodandtoverifythe relationship between oral health status and postoperative fever
using an oralbacteriacounter.Allpatientsreceivedperioperativeoralmanagement(POM)byoral specialists. Statistical analysis
revealed significantly higher oral bacteriacounts
at pre-hospitalization compared to pre- and post-operation (p < 0.001).They also found thatPOM can reduce the level of oral bacterial
counts, that therisk of postoperative
complications is lower with dentulous patients, and thatappropriatePOMisessentialforpreventofcomplications.
Therefore,theystated that POM may play an important role
in perioperative management oflungcancer patients.
OgawaPTetel(2020)[3]conductedaretrospectivecohortstudyon884consecutive patients who underwent
elective cardiovascular surgery to assessthe
impact of oral heath status on postoperative complications. They assessedtheoral
health status based on the number of remaining teeth, use of dentures,occlusalsupport,andperiodontalstatusandinvestigatedpostoperativecomplications.
On analyzing the collected data they found that prevalence ofpostoperative pneumonia and reintubation
after surgery was significantly higherinpatients with severetooth loss (P< 0.05for both).
Bardia A et
al(2019)[4]conducted a systemic review and
meta-analysis of 5studiesthatassessedtheeffectsofpreoperativechlorhexidinegluconatemouthwash on
postoperative pneumonia.Out of the
2284 patients that wereincluded, a
total of 1125 patients received preoperative chlorhexidine. All thestudiesrevealedthatuseofchlorhexidinegluconatewasassociatedwithreduced risk of
postoperative pneumonia compared with the patients who didnot receive it (risk ratio, 0.52; 95%
confidence interval, 0.39-0.70; P<.001). Noadverse effects from chlorhexidine gluconate mouthwash were reported by
anyofthesestudies.
SoutaneDDSetal(2017)[5]included539patientswithesophagealcancerundergoingsurgeryinamulticentercasecontrolstudytoinvestigatetheeffectiveness of
oral care in prevention of postoperative pneumonia. Patientsreceivedoralhealthinstruction,removalofdentalcalculus(scaling),professionalmechanicaltoothcleaning(PMTC),removaloftonguecoatingwithatoothbrush,cleaningdenture,andextractionofteethwithsevereperiodontitis showing pain, pus discharge,
mobility, or marked alveolar bonelossbyX-rayexamination.Patientswereinstructedtocleanteethbytoothbrush,interdentalbrush,dentalfloss,followedbygargling3timesaverday.Attheendoftheirstudy,theyfoundthatlongeroperationtime,postoperative
dysphagia, and lack of oral care intervention to be)significantlycorrelatedwith postoperativepneumonia.
Abbas K, Ahmad
SK(2016)[6] carried
out a randomised control trial to evaluatethe
use of the preoperative chlorhexidine antiseptic mouthwash on the incidenceofpostoperativepneumoniaon385patientsundergoingthoracicsurgery.Patientswererandomlydividedintotwogroups,onegroup(A)wasgivenchlorhexidine mouthwash 10ml of 0.2% (w/v)
preoperatively and the other (B)wasn’t.
They observed that the incidence of the postoperative pneumonia wassignificantly reduced in the patients
treated with preoperative chlorhexidinemouthwash
(group A 10.52% v group B 2.56% p=0.003). The length of hospitalstay was also found to be significantly shorter
in the chlorhexidine group. VAPdevelopment
rate was significantly higher in the control group than in the CHXgroup(68.8%vs.41.4%,respectively;p=0.03)withanoddsratioof3.12(95%
confidence interval = 1.09-8.91). Thus they came to the conclusion thatoralcarewithCHXswabbingreducestheriskofVAPdevelopmentinmechanicallyventilated patients.
Lin Y et
al(2015)[7] performed a prospective randomized
controlled trial toinvestigatetheeffectofpreoperative0.2%chlorhexidineonpostoperative
ventilatorassociatedpneumonia(VAP).Ninety-fourpatientsscheduledforheart surgery were randomized to a
chlorhexidine group (N = 47) or control(saline)
group (N = 47). On the day before surgery, patients gargled three timeswith 0.2% chlorhexidine or saline 30 min
after each meal and 5 min after teethbrushing
at bedtime. VAP occurred in 8.5% of the chlorhexidine group and in23.4%ofthecontrols.PreoperativechlorhexidinemouthwashreducedtheincidenceofpostoperativeVAPsignificantly.
Nicolosi L et
al(2014)[8] carried
out a quasi-experimental study on 300 patientsundergoing heart surgery to determine the effect of toothbrushing plus
0.12%chlorhexidinegluconateoralrinseinpreventingVAPafterCVS.
Patients in group 1 were enrolled in a
protocol for controlling dental biofilm byproper
oral hygiene (toothbrushing) and oral rinses with 0.12% chlorhexidinegluconate and they were compared with a
historical control group (Group 2),which
included patients who underwent cardiac surgery between 2009 and 2010andwhoreceivedregularoralhygienecare.Seventy-twohoursbeforesurgery,a dentist provided instruction and supervised oral hygiene with
toothbrushingand chlorhexidine oral
rinses to patients in Group 1. Statistics analysisshoweda
lower incidence of VAP and a shorter hospital stayin Group 1The risk fordeveloping
pneumonia after surgery was 3-fold higher in Group 2 hence theycameupwiththecponclusionthatoralhygieneandmouthrinseswithchlorhexidine under supervision of a
dentist proved effective in reducing theincidenceofVAP.
studyonsixty-onedentatepatientsscheduledforinvasivemechanicalventilation for at least 48 hours. As these patients were
variably incapacitated,oralcarewasprovidedbyswabbingtheoralmucosafourtimes/datwithchlorhexidine in the CHX group
(29 patients) and with saline in the controlgroup(32patients).Clinicalperiodontalmeasurementswererecorded,andlower-respiratory-tract
specimens were obtained for microbiological analysis onadmissionandwhenVAPwassuspected.Pathogenswereidentifiedbyquantifyingcolonies using standardculturetechniques.
Bagyi et al(2009)[10]conducted a study on a matched cohort of 18 patientswithout postoperative lung complications
comparing them to 5 patients whodeveloped
pneumonia within 48 hours after elective brain surgery. Patientsunderwent preoperative dental examination
and saliva collection before surgeryand
were given 15 mg/kg cefazolin intravenously at the beginning of surgery.Serum,salivaandbronchialsecretionwerecollectedpromptlyaftertheoperation. They observed that the number
and severity of coexisting periodontaldiseases
were significantly greater in patients with postoperative pneumonia incomparisontothecontrolgroupandtherelativeriskofdeveloping
postoperative pneumonia in high periodontal score
patients was 3.5 greater thanin
patients who had low periodontal score (p < 0.0001). Thus they concludedthat presence of multiple periodontal
diseases and pathogenic bacteria in thesaliva
are important predisposing factors of postoperative aspiration pneumoniainpatientsafterbrainsurgeryanddentalexaminationmaybewarrantedinorder to identify
patients at high risk of developing postoperative respiratoryinfections.
Houston S et
al(2002)[11] performed
a prospective, randomized, case-controlledclinicaltrialtotesttheeffectivenessof0.12%chlorhexidinegluconateoralrinseindecreasingmicrobialcolonizationoftherespiratorytractandnosocomialpneumoniainpatientsundergoingopenheartsurgery.Atotalof561patientsundergoingaortocoronarybypassorvalvesurgeryrequiringcardiopulmonary bypass were randomized to an experimental (n = 270)
groupthat received 0.12%
chlorhexidine gluconate or a control (n = 291) group thatreceivedListerine(phenolicmixture).NosocomialpneumoniawasdiagnosedbyusingthecriteriaestablishedbytheCentersforDiseaseControlandPrevention. overall rate
of nosocomial pneumonia was reduced by 52% (4/270vs 9/291; P = .21) in the Peridex-treated patients. Among
patients intubated formorethan24hourswhohadculturesthatshowedmicrobialgrowth(allpneumonias occurred in this group), the
pneumonia rate was reduced by 58%(4/19vs9/18;P=.06)inpatientstreatedwithPeridex.Inpatientsathighestriskforpneumonia(intubated>24hours,withculturesshowingthemostgrowth),theratewas71%lowerinthePeridexgroupthanintheListerinegroup(2/10 vs
7/10;P= .02).
DeRiso A et al(1996)[12] didaprospective,
randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlledclinicaltrialtotesttheeffectivenessoforopharyngealdecontamination on nosocomial infections in a comparatively
homogeneouspopulationofpatientsundergoingheartsurgery.Threehundredfifty-threeconsecutive patients undergoing coronary artery bypass grafting,
valve, or otheropen heart surgical
procedures were randomized to an experimental (n=173) orcontrol (n=180) group. The experimental drug chosen was 0.12% chlorhexidinegluconate (CHX) oral rinse. They found
that the overall nosocomial infectionrate
was decreased in the CHX-treated patients by 65%, the incidence of totalrespiratory tract infections in the
CHX-treated group was reduced by 69%.Gram-negative
organisms were involved in significantly less (p<0.05) of thenosocomial infections and total
respiratory tract infections by 59% and 67%,respectively. They also noted a reduction in mortality in the
CHX-treated group.Thus they
concluded that oropharyngeal decontamination with Chlorhexidineoral rinse reduces the total nosocomial
respiratory infection rate and the use ofnonprophylacticsystemicantibioticsinpatientsundergoingheartsurgery.
7.Novelty:
Existing studies have particularly targeted thoracic,
cardiac, bowel surgeries,neurosurgeries
and elderly patients with multiple comorbidities with focus ontheincidenceofpostoperativepneumoniainparticular.Thesesurgeriesfrequently require postoperative
mechanical ventilation with higher probabilityof developing postoperative pneumonia, irrespective of oral hygiene
status andmake up only a small
fraction of the spectrum of surgeries performed. In ourstudy, we seek to see the role of oral hygiene independently, by
removing thebiasofsurgerieswithahigherriskofpulmonarycomplications,basedonincidence of pneumonia as well as other
complications such as, unexplainedfever,excessivebronchialsecretions,productivecough,allofwhichsignificantlycontributetoperioperativemorbidity.
8.StudyObjectives:
The primary objective of the study is to see the
incidence of postoperativecomplications,
namely sore throat, pneumonia,fever,
URTI, LRTI, abnormalbreathsounds in both groups.
The secondary objectives are to see its role on surgical
site infections anddurationof hospital stay.
9.Methodology:
i.StudyDesign: Arandomizedcontrolledtrial
ii.SampleSize:
Thesamplesizewascalculatedbasedonapreviousstudythatreportedthat the prevalence of dental problems was 75% in India (Varghese et al,,2019),95%levelofconfidenceandErrorrate,usuallysetat0.05levelis
4.Total288patientswillbeincludedinthisstudy.
n=Z2P(1-P)/d2
Where,
â—n=samplesize,
â—Z=Zstatisticforalevelofconfidence,forthelevelofconfidenceof95%, which isconventional, Zvalueis 1.96.
VargheseCM,JesijaJS,PrasadJH,PricillaRA.Prevalenceoforaldiseases and risks to oral health in an
urban community aged above 14years.Indian J DentRes 2019;30:844-50
iii.Projectimplementationplan:
Theproposedstudyisaprospectiverandomizedcontrolleddoubleblindedstudyaimedtoidentifyroleofchlorhexidinemouthwashinpreventingpostoperativerespiratorycomplicationsinpatientsundergoingelectivesurgeriesunder general anaesthesia.
Patients of ASA grade I/II, with poor oral hygiene (OHI
more than 6), between18-65 years of
age posted for elective abdominal surgeries of less than 4 hours durationunder general anaesthesia using
endotracheal tube were included in the study.Patients undergoing laparoscopic surgeries, thoracic, cardiac and majorbowel surgeries andpatients in which supraglottic devices were used for GAwere excluded from the study. Patients
with active URTI/LRTI, COPD/asthma,activesmokers,withalcoholabuse,diabetesmellitus,morbidobesity,anyimmunedeficiency,heartinsufficiency,thosewithknownallergytochlorhexidine,
those on broad spectrum antibiotics and negative consent to participate in
trial will also be excludedfrom the
study. Patients who have not smoked for a year or longer will beclassified as not having a smoking habit. Patients in whom prompt
postoperativeextubation could not
be anticipated or neurological complications appeared, orthose requiring re-intubation or
re-exploration and those surgeries that extendbeyond4 hourswill bedroppedfromthestudy.
Aroutinestandardpreoperativecheckupwillbedone.Oralexaminationwillbe done by an experienced dentist. Eligibility and oral hygiene status
will begraded by the Oral Hygiene
Index (OHI). OHI is a dental index to assess thelevel oral hygiene a patient and has two components, Debris
Index(DI) andCalculusIndex(CI).Theseindicesinternisbasednumericaldeterminantrepresenting the amount of debris and calculus found on the
buccal and lingualsurfaces of each
of the three segments of both the dental arches. The maxillaryand mandibular arches are divided into 3
segments each. Segments 1 and 3 aredistaltotheleftandrightpremolarsrespectivelywhilesegment2extends
betweenthecanines.Eachsegmentisrepresentedbyonetooththathasthemost surface area covered by debris or
calculus. Only fully erupted permanentteeth
are scored and third molar and partially erupted teeth are not included.Debris is defined as soft foreign material
loosely attached to a tooth surface.Calculus
is a hard deposit formed by the mineralization of dental plaque. Aplaque is defined as a yellowish grey
substance that adheres tenaciously to anintraoral
hard surface. Each segment is scored from 0-3. Debris is scored as 0=no debris or stain present, 1= soft debris
covering less than 1/3rd of the toothsurfaceorpresenceofintrinsicstainswithoutotherdebrispresentirrespectiveof surface area covered, 2 = soft debris
covering more than 1/3rd but not morethan
2/3rd of exposed tooth surface, 3 = soft debris covering more than 2/3rd ofexposedtooth surface.
DI=debrisscore/numberofsegmentsscored
Calculusisscoredas0=nocalculuspresent,1=supragingivalcalculuscovering not
more than 1/3rd of the exposed tooth surface, 2=supragingivalcalculus
covering more than 1/3rd but not more than 2/3rd of the exposed toothsurface or presence of individual flecks of
sub gingival calculus around thecervical
portion of the tooth or both, 3= supragingival calculus covering morethan 2/3rd of the exposed tooth surface or
a continuous heavy band of thesubgingivalcalculusaround thecervical portionof thetooth orboth.
CI =
calculus score / number of segments scoredOHI=
CI+DI
All patients who
give informed consent after screening eligibility for participationin the study will be examined by an
experienced dentist one day prior to surgery toassessanddocumentactivecaries,thenumberofaffectedteethandwhetherperiodontal disease is present in the oral cavity. Active periodontal
disease, lostteeth and clinical
signs of acute infection will also record. All the patients will begivenpreoperativeantibioticprophylaxiswithinj.cefuroxime750mgivalongwith the two postoperative doses. They
will then be randomly divided into twogroups
by random computer-generated numbers in sealed envelopes. Group A willreceive 10 ml of chlorhexidine mouthwash
0.2% (w/v) for oral rinse to be done for10
minutes while group B will receive 10ml of saline mouthwash for oral rinse for10 minutes. Both the patient and the
observer will be blinded. A base line CBC will be collected in both the groups.
The patients will bethen
administered general anaesthesia using standard anesthetic drugs followed byendotracheal intubation. After
completion of surgery, extubation will be planned.Tracheal aspirate/broncho alveolar lavage for culture will be
collected just prior to extubationalong
withpostoperativeday3,and7 in whom culture will be positive or any
signs of infection present.CBC, ChestXRayandCRP
willbesentonday 3
and day 7 for same. Core body temperature,
incidence of sore throat, excessive bronchialsecretions, productive cough, abnormal broth sounds and need for
supplementaloxygen will be monitoredtill postoperative day 7. The diagnosis of
postoperativepneumonia or LRTI will
be made based on the guidelines for the management ofhospitalacquired
pneumonia, which include:
The diagnosis of postoperative
pneumonia required the presence of all the criteriain the patients. URTIwill
be defined as patients who have all the criteria forpneumonia,butdonothaveanewor
progressinginfiltrateonchest
radiograph.
The
data obtained, will be analysed using Statistical Package for SocialSciences, version 21.0 or above. Patients
will be compared between cases andcontrols.Chi-squaretest/Fisher exacttest
will beused.
10.Expectedoutcome:
Based on the trend seen in preceding studies, we expect
to find a positive co-relationbetweentheuseofpreoperativechlorhexidinemouthwashinpreventing postoperative pulmonary
complications. It has been observed thatrinsing
the mouth with an antiseptic solution prevents growth of pathogenicbacteria.Thus,wehopetoobservethatpreoperativemouthwashwithchlorhexidine in patients
with poor oral hygiene significantly prevents and/orreducestheincidenceofpneumoniaandotherassociatedrespiratorycomplicationsparticularlyinthosepatientswhowillbeundergonegeneralanesthesiaviaendotracheal intubation.
11.Limitationsofstudy:
11.Limitations of
study
•Studyissingle-centrewithsmallsamplesize.
Largesamplesizeisrequiredtoevaluatetheinfluenceofdiseasespeciesandsurgicalproceduresonpostoperativerespiratorycomplicationsin
each group
The effect of preoperative periodontal treatment on poor oral
hygiene patient as well as onhighrisksurgeriescanbebetterstudiedandanalysedwithbetterpostoperativeoutcomes
13.Timeline
Totaldurationofproject-2years
1)Period
needed for data collection-12 months2)Period
needed for follow up -6 months3)Periodneededfordataanalysis-6months
14.Institutionalsupport
Our institute has well developed general surgery department
with large number of patientsinput
for surgery, having well equipped modular operation theatre and post anesthesia
careunits. Ithasalsomicrobiologydepartmentwithadvancelaboratoriesandequipments.
1.Ploenes T,Pollok A,JöckelK,KampeS,DarwicheK, TaubeCetal.
Thepathological oral cavity as a
preventable source of postoperative pneumonia inthoracic surgery: a prospective observational study. Journal of
Thoracic Disease.2022;14(4):822-831.
2.Itohara
C, Matsuda Y, Sukegawa-Takahashi Y, Sukegawa S, Furuki Y, Kanno T.Relationship between Oral Health Status
and Postoperative Fever among PatientswithLungCancerTreatedbySurgery:ARetrospectiveCohortStudy.Healthcare.2020;8(4):405.
3.OgawaM,Satomi-KobayashiS,YoshidaN,TsuboiY,KomakiK,NanbaNetal.Impact
of Oral Health Status on Postoperative Complications and FunctionalRecoveryAfterCardiovascularSurgery.CJCOpen.2021;3(3):276-284.
4.Bardia
A, Blitz D, Dai F, Hersey D, Jinadasa S, Tickoo M et al. Preoperativechlorhexidinemouthwashtoreducepneumoniaaftercardiacsurgery:Asystematic review and
meta-analysis. The Journal of Thoracic and CardiovascularSurgery.2019;158(4):1094-1100.
5.Soutome S,
Yanamoto S, Funahara M, Hasegawa T, Komori T, Yamada S et al.Effectofperioperativeoralcareonpreventionofpostoperativepneumoniaassociatedwithesophageal cancersurgery.2022.
7.Lin Y, Xu L,
Huang X, Jiang F, Li S, Lin F et al. Reduced occurrence ofventilator-associated pneumonia after
cardiac surgery using preoperative 0.2%chlorhexidine
oral rinse: results from a single-centre single-blinded randomizedtrial.Journal of Hospital Infection. 2015;91(4):362-366.
8.Nicolosi
L, del Carmen Rubio M, Martinez C, Gonzalez N, Cruz M. Effect ofOralHygieneand0.12%ChlorhexidineGluconateOralRinseinPreventingVentilator-AssociatedPneumoniaAfterCardiovascularSurgery.RespiratoryCare.2013;59(4):504-509.
9.ÖzçakaÖ,BaşoğluÖ,BuduneliN, TaşbakanM,BacakoğluF,KinaneD.Chlorhexidine
decreases the risk of ventilator-associated pneumonia in intensivecare unit patients: a randomized clinical
trial. Journal of Periodontal Research.2012;47(5):584-592.
10.Bágyi K, Haczku
A, Márton I, Szabó J, Gáspár A, Andrási M et al. Role ofpathogenic oral flora in postoperative pneumonia following brain
surgery. BMCInfectiousDiseases. 2009;9(1).
11.Houston
S, Hougland P, Anderson JJ, LaRocco M, Kennedy V, Gentry LO.Effectiveness of 0.12% chlorhexidine
gluconate oral rinse in reducing prevalenceof
nosocomial pneumonia in patients undergoing heart surgery. Am J Crit Care.2002Nov;11(6):567-70.
12.DeRiso A,
Ladowski J, Dillon T, Justice J, Peterson A. Chlorhexidine Gluconate0.12%OralRinseReducestheIncidenceofTotalNosocomialRespiratoryInfection
and Nonprophylactic Systemic Antibiotic Use in Patients UndergoingHeartSurgery.Chest. 1996;109(6):1556-1561.