CTRI/2023/08/056026 [Registered on: 02/08/2023] Trial Registered Prospectively
Last Modified On:
09/01/2026
Post Graduate Thesis
Yes
Type of Trial
Interventional
Type of Study
Ayurveda
Study Design
Randomized, Parallel Group Trial
Public Title of Study
Effect of Shunthyadi Aschyotana (Eye drop), Mahatriphaladi Ghrita Pana and Anutaila Nasya in dry eye disease.
Scientific Title of Study
Efficacy of Shunthyadi Aschyotana (Eye drop), Mahatriphaladi Ghrita Pana and Anutaila Nasya in the management of Shushkaakshipaka (Dry eye disease)-An Open labelled Randomized clinical trial
Trial Acronym
NIL
Secondary IDs if Any
Secondary ID
Identifier
nil
NIL
Details of Principal Investigator or overall Trial Coordinator (multi-center study)
Name
Navya Pavithran
Designation
PhD scholar
Affiliation
Institute of Teaching and Research in Ayurveda
Address
opd no.3, Shalakya Tantra Department, Institute of Teaching and Research in Ayurveda, Jamnagar
Opposite to City B Police Division, Jamnagar
Jamnagar GUJARAT 361001 India
Phone
9400501212
Fax
Email
naminavya007@gmail.com
Details of Contact Person Scientific Query
Name
DeepakkPawar
Designation
Assistant Professor
Affiliation
Institute of Teaching and Research in Ayurveda
Address
4th floor, Shalakya Tantra Department, Institute of Teaching and Research in Ayurveda, Jamnagar
Opposite to City B Police Division, Jamnagar
Jamnagar GUJARAT 361001 India
Phone
7737379173
Fax
Email
drdeep29@gmail.com
Details of Contact Person Public Query
Name
Navya Pavithran
Designation
PhD scholar
Affiliation
Institute of Teaching and Research in Ayurveda
Address
opd no.3, Shalakya Tantra Department, Institute of Teaching and Research in Ayurveda,Opposite to City B Police Division, Jamnagar
Jamnagar GUJARAT 361001 India
Phone
9400501212
Fax
Email
naminavya007@gmail.com
Source of Monetary or Material Support
Institute of Teaching and Research in Ayurveda, Jamnagar
Primary Sponsor
Name
Institute of Teaching and Research in Ayurveda
Address
Opposite to City B Police Division Jamnagar
Type of Sponsor
Research institution and hospital
Details of Secondary Sponsor
Name
Address
NIL
NIL
Countries of Recruitment
India
Sites of Study
No of Sites = 1
Name of Principal
Investigator
Name of Site
Site Address
Phone/Fax/Email
Navya Pavithran
Institute of Teaching and Research in Ayurveda, Jamnagar
Opd no-3, Shalakya Tantra Department, Institute of Teaching and Research in Ayurveda, Opposite to City B Police Division, Jamnagar Jamnagar GUJARAT
09400501212
naminavya007@gmail.com
Details of Ethics Committee
No of Ethics Committees= 1
Name of Committee
Approval Status
Institutional Ethics Committee Institute of Teaching and Research in Ayurveda
Approved
Regulatory Clearance Status from DCGI
Status
Not Applicable
Health Condition / Problems Studied
Health Type
Condition
Patients
(1) ICD-10 Condition:H048||Other disorders of lacrimal system. Ayurveda Condition: SUSHKAKSHIPAKAH,
Intervention / Comparator Agent
sno
Intervention/Comparator
Type
Drug-Type
Procedure Name
Details
1
Intervention Arm
Procedure
-
nAvanam, नावनमà¥
(Procedure Reference: Susruta asamhita, Procedure details:
Poorva Karma: • Patient is advised to wash face & mouth with Luke warm water. • Abhyanga is done over forehead and cheeks. • Eyes are bandaged with a clean gauze piece over closed eyelids. • Then Swedana is done over the massaged area. Pradhana Karma: • The patient will be asked to lie in supine position extending his/her arms and legs and head slightly extended. • Later tip of the nose will be drawn upward by Vama Pradeshni (left index finger). • With right hand the )
) (1) Medicine Name: Anutaila, Reference: Ashtanga hrudaya sutra sthana, Route: Nasal, Dosage Form: Taila, Dose: 5(ml), Frequency: od, Duration: 14 Days
1. Irrespective of gender, caste, religion and socio-economic status.
2. Patients between age group of 18 and 60 years.
3. Patients presenting with minimum 3 symptoms and at least one positive test of Dry Eye Disease.
ExclusionCriteria
Details
1. Dry Eye due to any local cause e.g., Chemical Burn, Xerosis.
2. Dry Eye due to systemic disease like Sjogren’s Syndrome.
3. Patients on Steroids, Oral Contraceptive Pills, Estrogen Replacement Therapy, or any other medication such as Antispasmodic drugs like Atropine that may adversely affect the outcome of the study.
4. Persistent contact lens users.
5. Patients having chronic debilitating diseases like HIV, Tuberculosis, Malignancy, uncontrolled Diabetes Mellitus and uncontrolled Hypertension, Pregnant ladies and lactating mothers.
Method of Generating Random Sequence
Computer generated randomization
Method of Concealment
An Open list of random numbers
Blinding/Masking
Open Label
Primary Outcome
Outcome
TimePoints
Change in signs & symptoms of Shushkaakshipaka (Dry Eye Disease).
on 0(before treatment), 15th and 30th day(after treatment)
Secondary Outcome
Outcome
TimePoints
Assessment of recurrence of signs & symptoms of Shushkaakshipaka (Dry Eye Disease)
during follow up period on 15th & 30th day.
Target Sample Size
Total Sample Size="100" Sample Size from India="100" Final Enrollment numbers achieved (Total)= "0" Final Enrollment numbers achieved (India)="104"
Phase of Trial
Phase 2/ Phase 3
Date of First Enrollment (India)
01/11/2023
Date of Study Completion (India)
31/12/2025
Date of First Enrollment (Global)
Date Missing
Date of Study Completion (Global)
Date Missing
Estimated Duration of Trial
Years="1" Months="0" Days="0"
Recruitment Status of Trial (Global)
Not Applicable
Recruitment Status of Trial (India)
Completed
Publication Details
N/A
Individual Participant Data (IPD) Sharing Statement
Will individual participant data (IPD) be shared publicly (including data dictionaries)?
Response - YES
What data in particular will be shared? Response - All of the individual participant data collected during the trial, after de-identification.
What additional supporting information will be shared? Response - Study Protocol Response - Statistical Analysis Plan Response - Clinical Study Report Response - Analytic Code
Who will be able to view these files? Response - Researchers whose proposed use of the data has been approved by an independent review committee identified for this purpose.
For what types of analyses will this data be available? Response - To achieve aims in the approved proposal.
By what mechanism will data be made available? Response - Proposals should be directed to [naminavya007@gmail.com].
For how long will this data be available start date provided 01-11-2023 and end date provided 13-01-2029? Response - Beginning 3 months and ending 5 years following article publication.
Any URL or additional information regarding plan/policy for sharing IPD? Additional Information - nil
Shushkaakshipaka
classified as Sarvagata Netraroga among all the 76 Netrarogas by Acharya
Susruta and mentioned it as Vata predominant Vyadhi
characterized by Kunita Vartma (Narrowing of palpebral aperture), Daruna
Ruksha Vartma (Hardness and dryness at lid margin and cilia), Aviladarshana
(Blurring of vision), Sudarunam Yat Pratibodhane (Difficulty to open the
eyes/ Photophobia). According to Acharya Vagbhata it is a Vata-Pitta
predominant Vyadhi and has additional features such as Gharsha
(foreign body sensation), Toda (pricking pain), Bheda (Tearing
pain), Upadeha (Discharge/stickiness of lids), Rukshatwa, Darunatwa
of Vartma and Akshi (hardness and roughness of the eyelids and
eye), Sheetecha (desire for cold), Shula (Pain) and Paka
(Inflammation).
Dry
Eye Disease (DED) is a multifactorial disorder of the tears and ocular surface
characterized by loss of tear film homeostasis, resulting in ocular discomfort,
visual disturbance, and tear film instability, with potential damage to the
ocular surface. It is one of the most common ocular surface disorders
encountered in clinical practice, with a rising global prevalence ranging from
5% to 50%, particularly affecting the elderly, females, and individuals with
prolonged visual display terminal usage. Environmental factors, lifestyle
changes, aging, and systemic conditions contribute significantly to its
increasing incidence. Due to its chronic nature and impact on quality of life,
Dry Eye Disease represents an important public health concern. The last three decades have seen the awareness of dry eye
disease rise considerably around the world indicates rising of dry eye patients
mainly due to visual display terminal gadget usage and lack
of awareness of eye care. Prevalence
of dry eye disease is estimated to be 5% to 35% worldwide i.e., 1 out of every
3 to 7 patients could have this condition".The
prevalence of Dry eye disease is higher in India than the global prevalence,
ranging from 18.4% to 54.3%. It is estimated that 45% of patients older
than 40 years may have this problem. The mainstay of management of Dry Eye
Disease in contemporary medicine is by instillation of artificial tear
supplements, preservation of natural tears & excess mucous may be treated
by acetyl cystine & in severe cases some ocular surgeries. The tear
lubricants mentioned are a failure in reproducing the tears because the natural
tears are a complex mixture of lipids, mucin and water. Mainly this has a local effect only and, it can’t
break the root cause of pathology which often results in recurrence.
Also, the main problem is the cost of these medicines. These are prescribed as
lifelong therapy and many of the patients will not be in a position to afford
these expensive drops. This has paved
way for other medical systems, like Ayurveda, to propose experiments and offer
alternative treatments for the Dry eye syndrome.
AIM
To check and compare the
efficacy of Shunthyadi Aschyotana (Eye
Drop), Mahatriphaladi Ghrita Pana andAnutaila Nasya in the
management of Shushkaakshipaka (Dry
Eye Disease).
OBJECTIVES
OF THE RESEARCH
üPrimary
objectives- To evaluate the efficacy of trial drugs in reducing the irritation
or foreign body sensation and burning sensation in the eyes of patients with
Dry Eye Disease (Shushkaakshipaka)
üSecondary
objective -To assess the recurrence of signs and symptoms of Shushkaakshipaka(DryEyeDisease)
during follow up periodof 1 month.
METHODOLOGY
Review
of Shushkaakshipaka and Dry Eye
Disease were done in detail. The selected drugs were prepared in the pharmacy
of I.T.R.A., Jamnagar. The selected drug’s pharmacodynamics, pharmacognostical
of raw drug and the physiochemical analysis with different parameters of
prepared drugs were reviewed. The study came in progress after obtaining
ethical clearance by Institutional Ethics Committee with ethics approval no.-PGT/7/-A/Ethics/ 2023-24/760 dated 03/07/2023 and
registered in Clinical Trial Registry of India (CTRI) No. CTRI/2023/08/056026 registered
on 02/08/2023. Total 107 patients diagnosed to have Shushkaakshipaka with symptoms and signs were registered. The
randomization of selected patients was carried out by computerized simple
random table method and divided into 2 groups. 52 patients were completed the
study. Three patients who left against medical advice were later excluded from
the study. Group B received Shunthyadi Aschyotana (Eye Drop) two drops
thrice daily and Mahatriphaladi Ghrita Pana, 15ml once daily for 1 month.
In group A additionally, Anutaila Nasya (10 Bindu)- administered
in two sittings of Nasya for seven
days with the interval of seven days (total = 1month).Follow
up assessments occurred 45th and 60th day after
completion of treatment.
CONCLUSION
The
present study demonstrated that the intervention administered to Trial Group A
was more effective than Group B in managing dry eye disease, supporting the
alternate hypothesis. Primary outcomes reducing foreign body sensation and
burning sensation, showed significantly greater improvement in Group A (p <
0.05), highlighting superior symptomatic relief. Other subjective parameters,
including eye strain, dryness of the left eye, photophobia, and conjunctival
congestion, also showed significant advantages in Group A, while itching,
blurring of vision, and difficulty in open and close eyes were comparable
between groups. Objective assessments revealed that Group A achieved greater
enhancement in tear film stability (TBUT) and tear secretion (Schirmer-I test),
whereas improvements in fluorescein and Rose Bengal staining were similar
across both groups.With respect to the secondary objective of
assessing recurrence over a one-month follow-up, Group A exhibited a markedly
lower recurrence rate across most symptoms. Overall, the findings indicate that
the trial intervention in Group A provides clinically and statistically
superior efficacy in reducing key symptoms and improving tear dynamics in dry
eye disease, validating its therapeutic potential.Based
on these findings, the null hypothesis is rejected, and the alternate
hypothesis ie. Administration of Shunthyadi Aschyotana (Eye Drop), Mahatriphaladi
Ghrita Pana andAnutaila Nasya
(Eye Drop) is more effective than Shunthyadi Aschyotana (Eye Drop) and Mahatriphaladi
Ghrita Pana in the management
of Shushkaakshipaka (Dry Eye Disease) is accepted.