NEED FOR THE STUDY
Hrud
vyasa is a new technical term composed of Hrudaya and Vyasa. 1 One of
the Vata prakopa lakshanas is Vyasa, which means
asankocha(dilatation). It can happen in any organ or any part of the body, if
it happens in Hrudaya it may be considered as Hrud vyasa.
Left
ventricular hypertrophy 2 is enlargement and thickening of the walls
of the left ventricle. LVH is more common in people who have uncontrolled high
blood pressure. If it is left untreated leads to high risk of congestive heart
failure and irregular heart rhythms,is present in 15% to 20% of the general
population.3 It is often prevelant in blacks,the elderly, the obese,
and in patient with Hypertension.
Cardio
vascular diseases are leading cause of death globally, 17.9 million people died from Cardio vascular
disease in 2019, representing 30% of all global deaths. Of these deaths, 85%
were due to heart attack and stroke. Inspite of research and development in
cardiology, prevention of LVH in cases
of hypertension patients is not satisfactory.Hence there is scope for research
in Kayachikitsa and specially Hrudaya Marmaroga. The research question is
whether Rasayana chikitsa has a role to play in preventing the development of LVH in patients of hypertension who are under
treatment. A cost effective herbal or herbominerallo mettalic Rasayana is
needed in regular practice of preventive ayurvedic cardiology.
Chatushparni
is a combination of Shalaparni 4, Prishniparni5, Mudgaparni6,
Mashaparni 7 with Madhura, tikta, tridosha hara, Hrudya, Balya, Mutrala
and Rasayana effects. By vasodilatation, anti-arrythmic activity and
maintenance of HDL and lowering LDL effects reduce the load on heart and
improve cardiac muscle and vessel nutrition8 .
Sarpagandha
yoga is a combination of Rasasindura and Sarpagandha. Rasasindura 9
acts as Rasayana, sarvavyadhihara, yogavahi, prakrutisthapana, catalyst and
target specific action . Sarpagandha 10 is effective in Bhrama, Shoola,
Siragatavata and Anidra also proven anti-hypertensive11 drug
which helps in reducing afterload thus preventing further hypertrophy. The
alkaloid Reserpine is useful in hypertension and cardiovascular diseases12.
Both of the medicines are not explored for there potent cardiotonic activity and
there usefulness in preventive cardiology.The shamana yoga will be double
blinded in the present study to reduce the bias.
Hence
with the alternate hypothesis a herbal hrudya
yoga Chatushparni Rasayana and A Herbo-mineral Yoga Sarpagandha yoga is
effective in reducing Hrud Vyasa (Hypertension Induced Left Ventricular
Hypertrophy) has been taken with the title
“A DOUBLE BLIND RCT STUDY TO EVALUATE THE EFFICACY OF
CHATUSHPARNI RASAYANA AND SARPAGANDHA YOGA IN HRUD VYASA(HYPERTENSION INDUCED
LEFT VENTRICULAR HYPERTROPY)â€.
Diagnostic Criteria:
ü Symptoms like Hrutshoola (chest pain),Arohana ayasa
(exertional dyspneoa),Pratah shirashoola (early morning headache), Bhrama
(Giddiness), Nidra viparyaya(Insomnia), Dourbalya (weakness), Hrudrava
(palpitation), Amlodgara (sour belching),Padashopha (pedal oedema), Angamarda
(bodyache).
ü
TMT
ü
ECG
ü
2D-ECHOCARDIOGRAPHY - LVH GRADING BY POSTERIOR WALL THICKNESS
- MILD: 12 to 13mm
- MODERATE
>13 to 17mm
Inclusive criteria:
·
Diagnosed case of HYPERTENSION and LEFT
VENTRICULAR HYPERTROPHY on antihypertensive treatment will be taken.
·
Blood pressure- SBP
150-160mmHg
DBP 90-100mmHg
·
Patients between the age group of 30-65 years.
·
Patients with cornell criteria.
Exclusive criteria:
·
Who doesn’t provide informed consent
·
CCF
·
Multiorgan failure
·
Ejection fraction < 30%
·
Acute M.I
·
Pregnant and lactating women
Interventions: GROUP-A(20 PATIENTS) ·
Deepana pachana & Kosta
shodhana with Haritakyadi yoga 4gms with warm water(b/f) TID for 5 to 7
days or till samyak shodhana . ·
Chatushparni kashaya bhavita Chatushparni Rasayana 250mg capsule 2 BD before food for
45 days with Dashamuladi Kashaya anupana (15ml kashaya+60 ml warm water). GROUP-B (20 PATIENTS) ·
Deepana pachana & kosta
shodhana with Haritakyadi yoga 4gms with warm water(b/f) TID for 5 to 7
days or till samyak shodhana . ·
Sarpagandha kashaya bhavita Sarpagandha
yoga 250mg capsule 2 BD before food for 45 days with Dashamuladi Kashaya
anupana (15ml kashaya+60ml warm water). STUDY
DESIGN- ü PROSPECTIVE DOUBLEBLIND RANDOMIZED CLINICAL TRAIL ü ESTIMATED ENROLLMENT – 40 ü INTERVENTIONAL MODEL- 2 GROUP ASSIGNMENT ü ALLOCATION-RANDOMIZED ü MASKING- DOUBLE BLINDED ü STUDY DURATION – 55 ü FOLLOW UP-AFTER 15 DAYS Assessment criteria: The Assessment will be made as per
special case record format prepared. On the basis of 2D-Echocardiography
and E.C.G before and at the end of the trial. Based on both subjective and
objective parameters. Subjective criteria: Hrutshoola (chest pain),Arohana
ayasa (exertional dyspneoa),Pratah shirashoola (early morning headache), Bhrama
(Giddiness), Nidra viparyaya(Insomnia), Dourbalya (weakness), Hrudrava (palpitation),
Amlodgara (sour belching),Padashopha (pedal oedema), Angamarda (bodyache).
SI.NO
|
SYMPTOMS
|
SEVERITY
|
GRADE
|
1.
|
Hrutshoola (chest pain)
|
· No hrutshoola
· 1 or less than once a week, relieves without any intervention
· 2-3 times a week, relieves after mild rest
· More than 3 times a week, needs medical intervention
· Persistent
|
CS
CD1
CD2
CD3
CD4
|
2.
|
Arohana ayasa (exertional dyspneoa)
|
· No arohana ayasa
· Occurs once a week relieves without any intervention
· 2-3 times a week but does not affect daily routine relieves after
rest
· More than 3 times a week relieves after medical intervention
· Persistent, no relief at all.
|
CS
CD1
CD2
CD3
CD4
|
3.
|
PratahShirahshoola (early morning headache)
|
· No Pratah shirashoola
· Occurs once a week relieves without any intervention
· 2-3 times a week but does not affect daily routine relieves after
rest
· More than 3 times a week relieves after medical intervention
· Persistent, no relief at all.
|
CS
CD1
CD2
CD3
CD4
|
4.
|
Bhrama (giddiness)
|
· No bhrama
· Bhrama occurs once a week relieves without any intervention
· 2-3 times a week but does not affect daily routine relieves after
rest
· More than 3 times a week relieves after medical intervention
· Persistent, no relief at all.
|
CS
CD1
CD2
CD3
CD4
|
5.
|
Nidraviparyaya
|
· No nidra viparyaya
· Once a week, regains sleep,total sleep – 6-8 hours.
· 2-3 times a week,regains sleep after longer time total sleep-less
than 6hours.
· More than 3 times a week total sleep < 4hours
· Daily, sleep hours<3 hours
|
CS
CD1
CD2
CD3
CD4
|
6.
|
Dourbalya (weakness)
|
· No dourbalya
· Dourbalya occurs once a week relieves without any intervention
· 2-3 times a week but does not affect daily routine relieves after
rest
· More than 3 times a week relieves after medical intervention
· Persistent, no relief at all.
|
CS
CD1
CD2
CD3
CD4
|
7.
|
Hrudrava (palpitation)
|
· No hrudrava
· Palpitation after heavy physical excercise, subsides with rest
does not affect daily routine
· Palpitations without any physical activity, occurs 1-2 times a
week, subsides without medications
· Palpitations more than 3 times a week, patient on medications
· Persistent palpitations, no relief with medications.
|
CS
CD1
CD2
CD3
CD4
|
8.
|
Amlodgara(sour belching)
|
· No belching
· Feeling of belching with no sound
· Feeling of belching with mild sound
· Feeling of belching with moderate sound
· Feeling of belching with severe sound
|
CS
CD1
CD2
CD3
CD4
|
9.
|
Padashopha (pedal oedema)
|
· No pada shotha
· 1 or less than once a week, subsides without any intervention
· 2-3 times a week, subsides after limb elevation, rest etc.
· More than 3 times a week needs medical intervention
· Persistent
|
CS
CD1
CD2
CD3
CD4
|
10.
|
Angamarda (Bodyache)
|
· No angamarda
· 1 or less than once, does not affect daily routine
· 2-3 times a week, relieves after taking rest.
· More than 3 times a week relieves after taking analgesics
· Persistent, repeated body aches
|
CS
CD1
CD2
CD3
CD4
|
|