Introduction and
Need for study
Spinal Anaesthesia is a frequently employed
anaesthesia technique in clinical practice. It is usually preferred for infra umbilical
surgeries. However, most commonly noted complication following spinal
anaesthesia is Post spinal anaesthesia hypotension (PSAH). PSAH occurs as a
result of sympathetic blockade causing vasodilation of the arterioles,
eventually leading to hypo perfusion and ischemia of vital organs. Pre-operative
volume may differ depending upon the physical status, comorbidities, fasting,
that make the patients susceptible to intra operative hypotension. Timely
intervention is needed to prevent hypotension following spinal anaesthesia
thereby reducing morbidity and mortality among the patients.
Several measures such as intra vascular volume
preload or prophylactic vasopressors has been used to prevent intra operative
hypotension. But, these measures pose a danger of volume overload, especially
in patients with a pre-existing
cardiac or renal pathology.
Several
assessments have been tried to predict hypotension such as heart rate
variability, perfusion index and passive leg raise test with equivocal results.[1]
Ultrasonography
is emerging as an useful tool in daily clinical practice. Ultrasonography of
Inferior vena cava (IVC) during spontaneous respiration helps to assess the
volume status in a patient[2]. Measuring the collapsibility index of
IVC is found to be definitive, easy, low cost and non- invasive, yet it has its own limitations in patients
with upper abdominal tenderness, guarding of the abdomen, abdominal distension
or in bronchial asthma or any respiratory illness.
Axillary vein/Subclavian vein is found
to be an appropriate alternative for IVC to assess the volume status.[3]
Axillary/Subclavian
vein is located near the surface of the skin but is subject to less external
compression by the probe compared with the internal jugular or femoral veins
and is easily assessed in most patients by using a linear probe.
The goal of this study is to predict
hypotension in patients receiving spinal anaesthesia by assessing the
collapsibility index of infraclavicular axillary vein during spontaneous
respiration and deep inspiration.
REVIEW OF
LITERATURE
Choi
et al. studied the preoperative diameter and collapsibility index of the subclavian
vein (SCV) or infraclavicular axillary vein to predict the occurrence of
hypotension after induction of general anaesthesia in patients scheduled for
laparoscopic cholecystectomy. A total of 77 patients were recruited in this
study and 19 patients among them developed hypotension of 34.1± 6.6 mm Hg. They were noted to have a higher collapsibility index
of SCV during spontaneous breathing (P=0.009) and a higher collapsibility index
of SCV during deep inspiration (P=0.002). This study concluded that the
collapsibility index of the SCV during deep inspiration was a significant
predictor of occurrence of intraoperative hypotension and percentage fall in
MAP after general anaesthesia induction.[4]
Salama et al. evaluated the efficacy of IVC
collapsibility index (IVCCI) and IVC to aorta diameter (IVC: Ao) index,
measured pre-operatively for predicting post spinal anaesthesia hypotension. A
total of 100 patients were enrolled in the study of which 45 patients developed
PSAH and it was inferred that pre-operative IVCCI and IVC: Ao index are good predictors of occurrence of
PSAH, with IVC: Ao being a better predictor of PSAH.[5]
Ceruti
et al. evaluated the need for ultrasonography of IVC (IVCUS) guided volume
optimization to prevent post-spinal hypotension. A prospective, randomised,
cohort study, 160 patients scheduled for surgery under spinal anaesthesia were
categorised into IVCUS group and Control group (group C) where there was no
ultrasonography assessment made. The relative risk reduction of hypotension
between the groups was 35% and the need for vasoactive drugs in the IVCUS group
was relatively lower compared to the control group and the total amount of
fluid administered was significantly higher in the IVCUS group compared to the
control group. Here, IVC collapsibility was correlated with the amount of fluid
administered. They also concluded that IVCUS is an effective method to prevent
post spinal anaesthesia hypotension by administration of fluid through IVC via
ultrasonography guidance before spinal anaesthesia.[2]
Zhang
et al. studied the need for inferior vena caval ultrasonography before
induction of General anaesthesia to predict hypotension. A total of 104
patients were recruited, but only 90 patients were analysed as the IVC scanning
was unsuccessful in those 14 patients and mean blood pressure, maximum IVC
diameter and collapsibility index were noted preoperatively obtained from the
90 patients included in the study. This study inferred that pre-operative
ultrasonography was indeed a reliable predictor of hypotension after induction
of general anaesthesia where the collapsibility index more than 43% was
considered as threshold.[6]
Kent
et al. conducted a prospective study regarding the interchangeability of IVC
collapsibility index and SVC collapsibility index to assess intravascular
volume status in surgical intensive care patients where 34 patients
participated in the study. They underwent serial, paired assessment of IVC-CI
and SVC-CI using portable ultrasound devices. It was concluded that SCV
collapsibility index was a reasonable adjunct to IVCCI in surgical intensive
care unit patients and the correlation between the two techniques is acceptable
and overall measurement bias is noted to be low.[3]
OBJECTIVE OF THE STUDY:
Determination of collapsibility index of
the infraclavicular axillary vein during spontaneous respiration and deep
inspiration to predict hypotension post spinal anaesthesia.
MATERIAL AND
METHODS:
Source of data:
In this study, patients of either gender
aged between 18 and 65 years, undergoing elective surgeries requiring spinal
anaesthesia at M S Ramaiah Medical College and Hospital will be enrolled after
taking a written informed consent.
DURATION OF STUDY:
March 2021-October 2022.
20 months.
METHOD OF
COLLECTION OF DATA:
Sample size: 286 patients
The study by Kent et al. (184:561 -566) has shown
that IVC CI and SCV/AV CI has acceptable correlation. In the study by Salama et
al. (36:297- 302) the incidence of PSAH was 45%. Based on this findings with a absolute power of 5 and
desired confidence level of 95%, it is estimated that 286 patients need to be
recruited for this study.
TYPE OF STUDY: Prospective observational study
Inclusion criteria: Patients undergoing
elective surgery under spinal anaesthesia.
Aged above 18 -65 years
of either sex. ASA Physical Status
I and II.
Exclusion criteria:
Any
contraindications for spinal anaesthesia.
BMI>30kg/m2.
Pregnant women Emergency surgeries
Autonomic
neuropathy
Methodology:
Patients
fulfilling the inclusion criteria will be taken up for the study after written
informed consent.
In
the pre operative room, all patients will be lying supine, breathing
spontaneously for at least 5 minutes before examination, followed by ultrasonography
of the infraclavicular axillary vein using the Venue 40 (GE electronics)
instrument and a linear high frequency ultrasound probe by an experienced
anaesthesiologist. The axillary vein, beginning at the lower margin of the
teres major as a continuation of Brachial vein and continues its course
proximally until it terminates at the lateral margin of the first rib to become
the subclavian vein. The infraclavicular axillary vein lies in the
deltopectoral groove, deep to the pectoralis minor muscle. The probe is placed
in the sagittal plane over the middle third of the clavicle and traced laterally
to visualise the vein.
The
patients will be instructed to breathe normally at rest (spontaneous respiration)
and then to inspire as deeply as possible and expire naturally (deep
inspiration).The diameter of the infraclavicular axillary vein during
spontaneous respiration (dAVmin) and deep respiration (dAVmax) will be recorded
in M mode. The collapsibility index of the infraclavicular axillary vein will
be given by (dAVmax - dAVmin)/dAVmax *100.
No
prior fluid loading will be done. Baseline vitals such as heart rate, blood
pressure, and oxygen saturation will be noted during ultrasound study.
The
patient will then be transported to the operating theatre and vitals will be
noted just prior to administration of spinal anaesthesia with the patient lying
supine. Spinal anaesthesia will be performed with the subject in sitting
position at L3-L4 intervertebral space with 25G Quincke needle and 3 ml of Inj.
Bupivacaine 0.5% heavy will be administered. Patient will be immediately put in
supine position and heart rate, blood pressure and oxygen saturation will be
monitored every minute for the first ten minutes following which the vitals
will be measured every five minutes till the end of the surgery. There will be
neither any change in the position of the patient nor any surgical intervention
in the first ten minutes. The Anaesthetist who will be performing the
subarachnoid block and monitoring the intraoperative vitals will be blinded to
the ultrasonographic measurement of subclavian diameter and collapsibility
index. The level of spinal blockade, intra operative blood loss and volume of
fluid administered will be noted and assessed.
Crystalloids fluids
will be infused at a rate of 10ml/kg body weight/hour after spinal anaesthesia.
In
this study, intraoperative hypotension is defined as an absolute value of SBP
less than 90mm Hg or decrease in systolic blood pressure of more than 20% of
the baseline or an absolute value of MAP less than 60mm Hg. Patients will then
be divided into two groups depending on whether they develop PSAH or not.
Any episodes of hypotension will be treated with
fluid bolus of 200ml and if hypotension persists, bolus doses of IV of Inj. Ephedrine
6mg will be given. Inj. Atropine 0.6mg
IV will be given for bradycardia (HR<50bpm).
The
correlation between preoperative collapsibility index of infraclavicular vein
and developing hypotension will be assessed in this study.
Statistical Analysis:
Descriptive statistics will be employed to describe
the continuous variables such as age, height, weight, Body mass index (BMI),
etc. Percentages will be employed to describe categorical variables such as
gender, ASA physical status, development of hypotension, presence of
comorbidities, etc. Differences in the quantitative variables between the two
groups such as those who developed hypotension and who did not develop
hypotension will be tested for statistical significance by ‘Student t test’. In
case the data does not follow normal distribution, non-parametric tests of
significance will be employed. To test for differences in percentages between
those who developed hypotension versus those not developing hypotension will be
tested for statistical significance by Chi-square test of significance will be
employed. To find out the independent predictors for development of
hypotension, multivariate logistic regression analysis will be employed. Sensitivity, specificity, positive and negative
likelihood values will be estimated at different level of percentage deep
inspiration. To predict the patients who are likely to develop hypotension
versus not developing, receiver operating curve (ROC) drawn to estimate the cut
off levels of deep inspiration.
References
1. Duggappa DR, Lokesh M, Dixit A, Rinita
Paul, RS Raghavendra Rao, P Prabha. Perfusion index as a predictor of
hypotension following spinal anaesthesia in lower segment caesarean section. Indian J Anaesth 2017; 61:649 -654.
2. Ceruti S,
Anselmi L, Minotti B, D Franceschini, J Aguirre, A Borgeat, et al. Prevention of arterial
hypotension after spinal anaesthesia using vena cava ultrasound to guide fluid
management. Br J Anaesth 2018; 120:101 -108.
3. Kent A, Bahner DP,
Boulger CT, Daniel SE, Eric JA, David CE, et al. Sonographic evaluation
of intravascular volume status in the surgical intensive care unit: a
prospective comparison of subclavian vein and inferior vena cava collapsibility
index. J Surg Res 2013; 184:561 -566.
4.Choi
MH, Chae JS, Lee HJ, Woo JH. Pre-anaesthesia ultrasonography of the
subclavian vein/infraclavicular axillary vein for predicting hypotension after
inducing general anaesthesia: a prospective observational study. Eur J
Anaesthesiol.2020; 37:474 -48.
5.Salama
ER, Elkashlan M. Pre-operative
ultrasonographic evaluation of inferior vena cava collapsibility index and
caval aorta index as new predictors for hypotension, after spinal anaesthesia:
a prospective observational study. Eur J Anaesthesiol 2019; 36:297 -302.
6.Zhang J, Critchley LA. Inferior vena
cava ultrasonography before general anaesthesia can predict hypotension after
induction. Anaesthesiology 2016; 124:580 -589.
|