Study Design: Double
Blind, Prospective, Placebo Controlled, Randomised, Three Arm Clinical Study.
Indication:
Skin, Nail and Hair Health
Investigational
Product Test 1: Collagen Peptide
(Fish Source)
Investigational
Product Test 2: Collagen Peptide
(Bovine Source)
Comparator: Placebo
Study
Population: 72 Subjects; Adults
between 18 and 45 years of age (both ages and all sexes inclusive).
Treatment
Duration: 3 Months (90 Days)
RESULTS OF THE CLINICAL STUDY
Skin Improvement
Questionnaire
Bovine
Collagen: 46% of Subjects in this treatment group have achieved a Score of >20
in Skin Improvement Questionnaire in 90 Days. (Z = –0.39, p = 0.653 > 0.05).
End Point NOT Achieved.
Fish Collagen: 100% of Subjects in this
treatment group have achieved a Score of >20 in Skin Improvement
Questionnaire in 90 Days. (Z = 4.90, p = 0.000 < 0.05). End Point Achieved.
Placebo: 0% of Subjects in this treatment group have
achieved a Score of >20 in Skin Improvement Questionnaire in 90 Days. (Z =
-4.69, p = 1.000 > 0.05). End Point NOT Achieved.
Fish Collagen vs Placebo: 100% of
Subjects in “Collagen (Fish) group†have achieved a Score of >20 whereas, 0% of subject in Placebo group achieved a score of >20 in Skin Improvement Questionnaire in 90 Days.
Bovine Collagen vs Placebo: 46% of
Subjects in “Collagen (Bovine) group†have achieved a Score of >20 whereas, 0% of subject in Placebo group achieved a score of >20 in Skin Improvement Questionnaire in 90 Days.
Bovine Collagen vs Fish Collagen: Only 46% of the subjects in “Collagen
(Bovine) group†have achieved a Score of >20 in Skin Improvement
Questionnaire in 90 Days, while 100% of subjects (i.e., all the subjects) have
achieved such reduction in “Collagen (Fish) groupâ€.
60 Second Hair Count
Test
Bovine
Collagen : 50%
of Subjects in this treatment group have achieved a reduction of 20% in 60 Second Hair Count Test in 90 Days. (Z = 3.88, p = 0.000 < 0.05). End Point NOT Achieved
Fish Collagen: 100% of Subjects in this treatment group have
achieved a reduction of 20% in 60 Second Hair Count Test in 90 Days. (Z = 4.90, p = 0.000 < 0.05).End
Point Achieved
Placebo: 0% of Subjects in this treatment group have
achieved a reduction of 20% in 60 Second Hair Count Test in 90 Days. (Z = -4.69, p = 1.000 >
0.05). End Point NOT Achieved.
Fish Collagen
vs Placebo: 100%
of Subjects (i.e., all the
subjects) have achieved 20% reduction in “Collagen (Fish) group†whereas, 0% of
subject in Placebo group achieved a reduction of 20%
in 60 Second Hair Count Test
in 90 Days.
Bovine
Collagen vs Placebo: 50% of Subjects
in “Collagen (Bovine) group†have
achieved a reduction of 20% whereas,
0% of subject in Placebo group achieved
a reduction of 20% in 60 Second
Hair Count Test in 90 Days.
Bovine
Collagen vs Fish Collagen: 50% of the subjects in “Collagen (Bovine) group†have
achieved a reduction of at least 20% in Hair Count Test score, whereas, 100% of
subjects (i.e., all the subjects) have achieved such reduction in “Collagen
(Fish) groupâ€.
Hair Growth Questionnaire
Bovine Collagen: 42% of Subjects in this treatment group have achieved
a Score of >20 in Hair Growth Questionnaire in 90 Days.
(Z = –0.78, p = 0.784 > 0.05). End Point NOT Achieved
Fish Collagen:
100% of Subjects in this treatment group have achieved a Score of >20
in Hair Growth Questionnaire in 90 Days. (Z = 4.90, p = 0.000 < 0.05).End
Point Achieved
Placebo: 0% of Subjects in this treatment
group have achieved a Score of >20 in Hair Growth Questionnaire in 90 Days.
(Z = -4.69, p = 1.000 > 0.05). End Point NOT Achieved
Fish
Collagen vs Placebo: 100% of Subjects in “Collagen (Fish) group†have achieved a Score of
>20 whereas, 0% of subject in Placebo group achieved
a score of >20 in Hair Growth
Questionnaire in 90 Days.
Bovine
Collagen vs Placebo: From Visit 1 to Visit 3: According to the result of
Single Proportion Test, 42% of Subjects in “Collagen (Bovine) group†have
achieved a Score of >20 whereas, 0% of subject in Placebo group achieved
a score of >20 in Hair Growth
Questionnaire in 90 Days.
Bovine
Collagen vs Fish Collagen: From Visit 1 to Visit 3:
According to the result of Two-Proportion test, the null hypothesis is rejected
at 5% level of significance (Z = –4.45,p = 0.000 < 0.05). Only 42% of the
subjects in “Collagen (Bovine) group†have achieved a Score of >20 in Hair
Growth Questionnaire in 90 Days, while 100% of subjects (i.e., all the
subjects) have achieved such reduction in “Collagen (Fish) groupâ€
Nail
Health Questionnaire
Bovine
Collagen: 42% of Subjects in this treatment group have
achieved a Score of >20 in Nail Health Questionnaire in 90 Days. (Z = –0.78, p = 0.784 > 0.05). End
Point NOT Achieved
Fish
Collagen: 100% of Subjects in this treatment group have
achieved a Score of >20 in Nail Health Questionnaire in 90 Days. (Z = 4.90,
p = 0.000 < 0.05).End Point Achieved
Placebo: 0% of Subjects in this treatment
group have achieved a Score of >20 in Nail Health Questionnaire in 90 Days.
(Z = -4.69, p = 1.000 > 0.05). End Point NOT Achieved
Fish
Collagen vs Placebo: 100% of Subjects in “Collagen (Fish) group†have achieved a Score of
>20 whereas, 0% of subject in Placebo Group achieved a score of >20 in Nail Health Questionnaire in 90 Days.
Bovine Collagen vs Placebo: 42% of Subjects in “Collagen (Bovine)
group†have achieved a Score of >20 whereas, 0% of subject in Placebo
Group have achieved a score
of >20 in Nail Health
Questionnaire in 90 Days.
Bovine Collagen vs Fish Collagen:
42% of the subjects in “Collagen (Bovine) group†have achieved a Score
of >20 in Nail Health Questionnaire in 90 Days, while 100% of subjects
(i.e., all the subjects) have achieved such reduction in “Collagen (Fish) groupâ€.
Safety
Results
No adverse event was reported in this
clinical study. The safety investigations also showed no clinical difference
from baseline to end of the study.
Overall Study Conclusion: Overall,
it is concluded that Fish Collagen was
effective in the improving skin, hair
and nail health in 90 days. No adverse event was reported upon
consumption of both Bovine Collagen and Fish Collagen. The
safety investigations also showed no clinical difference from baseline to end
of the study. Based on the results of this Clinical Study Report,
Fish Collagen Peptide of Titan Biotech Limited/Stalwart Nutritions Pvt. Ltd is
recommended as a safe and effective therapy in the improving skin, hair and
nail health. |