Introduction
Steroid responsive dermatoses such as lichen planus pemphigus vulgaris discoid lupus erythematosus and severe atopic dermatitis require systemic corticosteroids to achieve rapid disease control. Prednisolone is commonly prescribed because of strong anti inflammatory and immune suppressing actions. Long term use of Prednisolone can lead to adverse effects such as cushingoid features skin thinning acne like eruptions and disturbances in metabolism which can reduce treatment adherence and affect quality of life.
Deflazacort is a corticosteroid that is structurally related to Prednisolone and has similar therapeutic action with a potentially better safety and tolerability profile. It has less impact on carbohydrate metabolism and causes less loss of calcium making it useful in long term management of chronic inflammatory skin disorders. However there is limited dermatology specific evidence comparing the clinical effectiveness and safety of Deflazacort and Prednisolone. Many published reports are isolated cases or based on non dermatology systemic diseases.
Therefore there is a need for a systematic comparative study to evaluate the clinical efficacy safety and patient tolerability of Deflazacort and Prednisolone in steroid responsive dermatoses. This study aims to generate evidence that can support rational corticosteroid selection in dermatology clinical practice. Justification
Systemic corticosteroids are a key part of therapy in many steroid responsive dermatoses where topical medicines alone are not sufficient. Prednisolone is widely used but its side effects are dose and duration dependent and they limit long term safety and patient adherence. Deflazacort has been promoted as having better metabolic safety and tolerability but its adoption in dermatology remains limited due to lack of strong comparative evidence in skin diseases.
Existing comparative studies mainly focus on specialties such as nephrology and rheumatology and do not provide dermatology specific evidence. This gap makes it important to evaluate the comparative clinical performance and safety of Prednisolone and Deflazacort in dermatology. This study is therefore justified to support safe and effective corticosteroid selection minimize side effects and improve treatment outcomes in steroid responsive dermatoses. Objectives
Primary objective
To compare the clinical efficacy of Prednisolone and Deflazacort in steroid responsive dermatoses
Secondary objective
To compare the frequency and severity of adverse effects associated with Prednisolone and Deflazacort therapy Methods and Methodology
Study design
Prospective comparative open label parallel group study conducted in the Dermatology Outpatient Department of a tertiary care teaching hospital
Study setting
Tertiary care teaching hospital located in Chengalpattu district
Study population
Patients attending the dermatology outpatient department during the study period Sample size
Based on earlier published studies the minimum required sample size is calculated as forty six participants with twenty three participants in each treatment group Study period
The duration of the study is eighteen months Study tool
A pretested validated structured questionnaire will be used to collect the following information
Sociodemographic profile
Clinical profile
Treatment details Ethical clearance
Ethical approval will be obtained from the Institutional Human Ethics Committee of Chettinad Hospital and Research Institute before starting the study. Written informed consent will be obtained from all participants. Data confidentiality and participant anonymity will be maintained throughout the study. Inclusion criteria
Adults aged between eighteen and sixty five years
Clinically diagnosed with steroid responsive dermatoses including atopic dermatitis allergic contact dermatitis irritant contact dermatitis lichen planus discoid lupus erythematosus urticaria with angioedema disseminated eczema and immunobullous disorders
Requiring systemic corticosteroid therapy based on the decision of the treating dermatologist
Willing and able to provide written informed consent
Willing to comply with the study protocol and follow up visits Exclusion criteria
Known hypersensitivity or contraindication to Prednisolone or Deflazacort
Presence of uncontrolled diabetes hypertension peptic ulcer disease or active infections including tuberculosis
Current use of immunosuppressive medicines other than corticosteroids
Pregnant or lactating women
History of psychiatric illness or substance abuse affecting compliance
Use of systemic corticosteroids within the last four weeks
Known renal or hepatic dysfunction based on recent laboratory reports Data collection
Data collection will begin after ethical clearance and informed written consent. Data will be collected through interview using a pretested semi structured questionnaire. Statistical analysis
Data will be entered in Microsoft Excel and analyzed with statistical software. Quantitative variables will be expressed in descriptive statistics. Statistical significance will be determined using chi square test and probability value less than zero point zero five will be considered significant. Sampling procedure and follow up schedule
Eligible participants will be enrolled consecutively after informed consent until the required sample size is reached. Participants will be randomized in a one to one ratio into two groups Group A Prednisolone and Group B Deflazacort using a computer generated block randomization method. The study will be open label.
Participants will be assessed at baseline and at regular intervals until the end of the study period. Follow up visits will be scheduled at day seven day fourteen day twenty eight week six and week eight. Outcome parameters such as lesion score symptom improvement treatment tolerability adverse effects and Dermatology Life Quality Index score will be recorded at each follow up. Unscheduled visits will be allowed for disease flares relapses or significant adverse effects. All adverse events will be documented and managed appropriately. Study outcomes
The study will determine the difference in clinical efficacy of Prednisolone and Deflazacort in steroid responsive dermatoses
The study will compare the safety and frequency of adverse effects in both treatment groups
The study will evaluate patient satisfaction and treatment adherence Questionnaire Section A Demographic and clinical information
Age in years
Gender male female or other
Occupation
Residence rural or urban
Educational status illiterate primary school secondary school higher secondary graduate and above Section B Baseline questions
Alcohol consumption never occasionally or daily
Tobacco use never smoker chewer or both
Height in centimeters
Weight in kilograms
Body mass index
History of comorbidities including hypertension diabetes asthma tuberculosis or others Section C Clinical assessment
Provisional dermatological diagnosis
Duration of illness before treatment
Presenting symptoms such as itching redness pain blistering scaling ulceration discoloration and others
Baseline severity as assessed by physician mild moderate or severe
Number of relapses in the past six months
History of similar illness in family yes or no
Previous systemic steroid use yes or no
Current medications Section D Treatment details
Drug received Prednisolone or Deflazacort
Initial dose
Planned duration of treatment
Tapering advised yes or no
Concurrent medications
Previous treatment received for skin disorder including none topical treatment only systemic corticosteroids or traditional alternative therapies
Previous adverse reaction to steroids yes or no specify if yes
Symptom improvement based on itching redness and lesions no improvement mild improvement moderate improvement marked improvement or complete clearance
Number of days to first noticeable clinical improvement
Overall disease control compared to baseline poor fair good or excellent Section E Side effects during treatment
Presence of the following during or after starting treatment
Weight gain
Facial puffiness or swelling
Increased appetite
Sleep disturbance
Mood changes such as low mood anger or anxiety
Acne or pimples
Stomach pain or acidity
Easy bruising or thin skin
Muscle weakness especially arms or legs
Frequent infections or general unwell feeling
Stretch marks
Any other side effects
Section F Dermatology Life Quality Index
Evaluation of effect of skin disease on daily activities relationships personal confidence work studies social activities leisure activities sexual life and difficulties caused by treatment over the previous week.
Total score will be computed out of thirty. |