|
1.
Title of the project: Comparison of effects of 0.5% levobupivacaine
heavy versus 0.5% bupivacaine heavy in patients undergoing
transurethral resection of prostate under spinal anaesthesia.
2.
Type of study: A prospective,single-blinded, randomized study
3.
Aims and Objectives:
Primary
Objectives:
To
compare the effects of 2 ml of 0.5% levobupivacaine heavy and 2 ml of
0.5% bupivacaine heavy in patients undergoing transurethral resection
of prostate under spinal anaesthesia by the following parameters:
a)
Time taken for onset of sensory and motor blockade
b)
Time taken to achieve a maximum sensory level
c)
Time taken for 2-segment regression
d)
Time taken for sensory and motor recovery
Secondary
Objectives:
To
compare the effects of 2 ml of 0.5% levobupivacaine heavy and 2 ml of
0.5% bupivacaine heavy in patients undergoing transurethral resection
of prostate under spinal anaesthesia by the following parameters:
a)
Hemodynamic changes
b)
Frequency of adverse events
4.
Justification for study: Spinal anaesthesia is a popular technique of
anaesthesia in uro-genital surgeries. Many of the patients who
undergo transurethral resection of the prostate are elderly and
present with multiple co-morbidities. Marked hypotension may be
detrimental especially in elderly with limited cardiac reserve.
Spinal anaesthesia is well tolerated by this age group as it doesn’t
involve airway manipulation or polypharmacy, provides good intra and
post-operative analgesia and minimizes surgical blood loss while
enabling swift identification of complications during transurethral
resection of prostate (overhydration, water intoxication or bladder
rupture).
Bupivacaine
is a commonly used local anaesthetic in spinal anaesthesia. Due to
its high affinity to plasma proteins, it does not elicit clinical
signs of drug accumulating in the plasma until an advanced stage.
Once the plasma protein binding sites are exhausted, the
concentration of the drug increases rapidly and signs of toxicity
manifest.
Levobupivacaine,
an isomer of bupivacaine is less cardiotoxic as it has a low affinity
for cardiac sodium channels and a high affinity for plasma proteins
owing to the lower affinity of the S (−) isomer to cardiac sodium
channels compared to the R isomer, it is associated with less cardiac
side effects.
5.
Departments involved: Department of Anaesthesiology, Kasturba Medical
College, Manipal.
6.
Study Period: The study will begin after obtaining approval from the
Institutional Ethics Committee. The duration of the study will be
from 2024 -2026 (2 years).
7.
Sample Size: To be calculated after the pilot study
8.
Materials and Methods: A prospective randomized control study will be
done in patients undergoing transurethral resection of prostate under
spinal anaesthesia.
Inclusion
Criteria:
a)
50-75 years of age
b)
BMI of 18-30 kg/m2
c)
ASA I, II, III
Exclusion
Criteria:
a)
Unable to follow simple commands
b)
Raised Intracranial pressure
c)
Infection at the site of administration of spinal
d)
Hypersensitivity to local anaesthetic
f)
Coagulopathy
e)
Sepsis
f)
Uncorrected hypovolemia
Biological
materials required: Nil
Statistical
Methods: Numerical variables will be presented as mean & standard
deviation (SD) and unpaired student-t test will be done. Categorical
variables will be presented as percent and will be analysed using
Pearson’s chi-square.A p-value of 5% will be considered
significant.
Tools
Used: Nil
9.
Detailed description of procedure:
Observers:
Observer 1: Anaesthesia faculty who is not otherwise involved in the
study prepares the solution to be administered intrathecally based on
the computer generated random number table allocation of the group.
Observer
2: Anaesthesiology postgraduate involved in the study (blinded to the
drug given intrathecally) will record the onset of sensory and motor
blockade, maximum level of sensory and motor block, time to recovery
from sensory and motor blockade, haemodynamic parameters and any
complications arising during the study period.
Randomization
and Group Allocation:
Patients
will be randomly allocated into one of the 2 groups using computer
generated random number table.
Group
L: (Group Levobupivacine): Patients in this group will receive 2 ml
of 0.5% levobupivacaine intrathecally.
Group
B: (Group Bupivacaine): Patients in this group will receive 2 ml of
0.5% hyperbaric bupivacaine intrathecally.
Both
bupivacaine and levobupivacaine will be stored in room temperature in
the OT storage room.
Procedure:
A
detailed preoperative evaluation of the patient will be done one day
prior to surgery by the anaesthesiology postgraduate. Written
informed consent will be obtained and all patients will be kept nil
per oral (6 hours for solids and 2 hours for clear fluids).
On
the day of the surgery, the patient will be shifted to the operating
theatre where standard monitors (pulse oximeter, non-invasive blood
pressure and 5 lead Echocardiography) will be attached. The baseline
heart rate, blood pressure and oxygen saturation will be recorded. An
intravenous line will be secured with an 18 Gauge cannula and
intravenous infusion of Ringer’s lactate will be started.
Patients
will be positioned in the left lateral decubitus position. Under
sterile precautions, spinal anaesthesia will be administered by
observer 2 at the level of the L3 - L4 or L4 - L5 intervertebral
space with 23 gauge Quincke- Babcock spinal needle. Once free flow of
cerebrospinal fluid is obtained, the study drug will be injected
intrathecally over a period of 10 seconds. Patients will be placed in
the supine position immediately after intrathecal injection and the
time of intrathecal drug injection will be noted as time zero “0â€.
Co-loading with Ringer Lactate solution will be started at a rate of
10ml/kg in the first hour.
A
cold alcohol swab will be used to check appreciation of temperature.
As pain and temperature sensations are both carried by A-delta
fibres, the inability to appreciate cold sensation will be taken as a
surrogate for analgesia. Check with the cold swab will be performed
every 2 minutes along the midclavicular line on both sides. The
higher of the two sides will be taken as the end point for this
parameter.
Onset
of analgesia at T10 will be noted. The sensory level will be checked
every 2 minutes as described above until the level does not ascend
any further for 4 consecutive readings. This dermatomal level will be
noted as the highest level of analgesia. Sensory level will be
checked every 5 minutes thereafter till the end of 30 minutes, and
every 10 minutes thereafter till 2-segment regression (defined as
recovery of sensory block by 2 segments from the highest level
achieved in that patient) and sensory recovery (around S2-S4
segments) occur.
Motor
blockade will be assessed by modified Bromage scale (0 = no
paralysis, able to flex hip/knee/ankle; 1 = able to flex knee and
ankle, unable to raise extended leg; 2 = able to flex ankle, unable
to flex hip and knee; 3 = unable to flex hip, knee and ankle). Motor
blockade will be evaluated at 2-minute intervals till a modified
Bromage score of 3 is obtained or till maximum motor blockade is
achieved. This time is noted as onset of motor blockade. The time at
which ankle movement returns is noted to indicate recovery from motor
blockade.
In
case of requirement of rescue analgesia, spinal anaesthesia will be
supplemented with analgesics as and when needed.
Blood
pressure will be recorded every 5 minutes for the first half an hour
and every 10 minutes thereafter. Hypotension after spinal anaesthesia
will be defined as an absolute value of SBP less than 100mmHg, or a
decrease in SBP by more than 20% of the baseline value or an absolute
value of MBP less than 60mmHg. Episodes of hypotension will be
treated using intravenous boluses of mephentermine 3 mg/ Ephedrine
bolus of 6mg.
Heart
rate will be recorded every 5 minutes for the first half an hour and
every 10 minutes thereafter. A heart rate < 50/min will be
considered as bradycardia but will be treated with atropine 0.6 mg
only if associated with hypotension.
A
respiratory rate less than 8/min or pulse oximetry values less than
95% on room air will be taken as significant and oxygen via face mask
or nasal prongs will be supplemeted at 4L/minute.
Any
adverse effects such as nausea, vomiting, shivering, pruritus will be
noted and managed accordingly.
10.
Potential risks and benefits: Standard risks pertaining to spinal
anesthesia and transurethral resection of prostate.
Benefits:
Drug giving better hemodynamic stability can be used in elderly
patients
11.
Ethical considerations and methods to address issues: The study
requires approval from the Institutional Ethics Committee. lnformed
consent will be obtained from the participants. Patients have the
right to opt out of the study at any time during the study period
with no compromise on their subsequent medical treatments and
benefits to which they are entitled. No direct identifiers will be
collected, hence ensuring confidentiality. Standard anaesthetic
techniques will be used in all patients and strict asepsis will be
followed.
12.
Budget: Rs 5000
Patients
will be compensated for the cost of 0.5 % bupivacaine heavy ( Rs 35)
and 0.5 % levobupivacaine heavy (Rs110).
|